How to protect your circuit design from being copied ？

Protecting your circuit design from being copied is a critical concern for engineers and companies. Here's a comprehensive approach combining legal, technical, and strategic methods:

1. Legal Protection

Patents

  • Utility Patents: Protect novel, non-obvious functional aspects of your circuit

  • Design Patents: Protect the unique physical layout/ornamental appearance

  • Process: File with USPTO (or equivalent in your country) - requires public disclosure but provides strong legal recourse

Copyright

  • Protects schematic diagrams, PCB layouts, and documentation

  • Automatic upon creation (but register for stronger protection)

  • Doesn't protect functional aspects, only expression

Trade Secrets

  • Keep designs confidential with NDAs and restricted access

  • No expiration but protection lost if design is reverse-engineered

2. Technical Protection Methods

Secure Microcontrollers/Processors

  • Encrypted Bootloaders: Prevent firmware extraction (e.g., STM32 with RDP)

  • Secure Elements: Dedicated security chips (e.g., ATECC608A, A1006)

  • Hardware Security Modules (HSMs): For high-security applications

Programmable Logic Protection

  • Encrypted Bitstreams: FPGAs/CPLDs with configuration encryption (Xilinx, Intel)

  • Anti-Tamper Features: Zeroize keys upon detection of tampering

PCB-Level Obfuscation

  • Multi-layer Boards: Hide critical traces in inner layers

  • Blind/Buried Vias: Conceal interconnection points

  • Conformal Coating: Opaque epoxy coatings to hide components

  • Component Scrubbing: Remove identifying markings

Active Protection Circuits

  • Tamper Detection: Switches/sensors that wipe memory if enclosure opened

  • Voltage/Temperature Monitors: Trigger countermeasures if out-of-spec

  • Clock/Power Glitch Detection: Prevent timing/power analysis attacks

3. Firmware & Software Protection

Code Protection

  • Obfuscation: Make reverse-engineering difficult

  • Encrypted Storage: Keep firmware encrypted in external memory

  • Secure Boot: Verify digital signatures before execution

  • Anti-Debugging Techniques: Detect and respond to debugging attempts

Runtime Protection

  • Checksums: Verify code integrity during execution

  • Heartbeat Monitoring: Detect if code has been modified or stopped

  • Secure Communications: Encrypt all external communications

4. Supply Chain Security

Controlled Manufacturing

  • Trusted Foundries: Use reputable PCB assembly houses with NDAs

  • Split Manufacturing: Different vendors for different layers/stages

  • Component Obfuscation: Use custom-marked or slightly modified components

Secure Distribution

  • Encrypted Updates: Secure firmware update mechanisms

  • License Management: Hardware dongles or activation keys

  • Serialization: Track individual units and detect counterfeits

5. Strategic Approaches

Product Design Strategies

  • Integration: Use ASICs or custom SoCs where economical

  • Minimalist Design: Remove identifying silkscreen and documentation

  • Value in Software: Keep core value in protected software/firmware

Business Practices

  • NDAs: With employees, contractors, and partners

  • Employment Agreements: Include IP assignment clauses

  • Compartmentalization: Limit knowledge across teams

6. Detection & Enforcement

Monitoring

  • Market Surveillance: Regularly check for clones/counterfeits

  • Trap Features: Include identifiable but non-functional circuit elements

  • Watermarking: Hidden signatures in PCB layout or firmware

Legal Action

  • Cease & Desist Letters: Initial formal notice

  • DMCA Takedowns: For online sales of copied designs

  • Litigation: For significant infringement cases

Practical Implementation Example

For a Commercial Product:

  1. File provisional patent for novel circuit aspects

  2. Use microcontroller with RDP Level 2 (STM32) or secure element

  3. Implement encrypted firmware updates with rollback protection

  4. Apply opaque conformal coating and use multi-layer PCB

  5. Require NDAs with manufacturer and document all access

  6. Include tamper detection that wipes cryptographic keys

Key Considerations

  • Cost vs. Protection: Balance security measures with product cost

  • Layered Approach: No single method is perfect - use multiple layers

  • International Protection: Consider patents in countries where manufacturing occurs

  • Continuous Evaluation: Regularly update protection methods as threats evolve

Remember: No protection is 100% secure, but you can make reverse engineering sufficiently difficult and expensive that it's not worthwhile for most potential copiers.

Back to Lisa's Column